Ten years ago, 17-year-old high school volleyball star Callie Jones vanished from her quiet Wisconsin lake community. Her body was never found, and the case went cold, but the echoes of Callie’s disappearance still linger. On the tenth anniversary, Ethan Hall—a former renegade detective turned doctor—is tapped to re-open the case.

Like most fans of The Perfect Marriage, I could not wait for the sequel.

Imagine the stupid decisions you made back in high school, we all have something we look back on and shudder. Now imagine one of those decisions being so stupid they can change the trajectory of your lives forever.