Everybody Wants Authenticity Until You Actually Have an Opinion

Everybody loves to tell you to be yourself.

"Speak your truth."

"Stop worrying about what other people think."

"Don't dim your light for anybody."

Beautiful advice. Very empowering. Looks fantastic on a coffee mug.

But have you noticed how quickly all that encouragement disappears when being yourself involves having an opinion someone doesn't particularly like?

Suddenly, you're negative. Difficult. Judgmental. Maybe even intimidating.

Apparently, authenticity comes with terms and conditions.

Be yourself. Just make sure it's the version of yourself that everybody else finds agreeable.

Well, that's convenient.

Everybody Loves Honesty. Until They Hear Some.

I've always found it interesting when someone asks for an honest opinion and then gets offended by the answer.

"Tell me what you really think."

Are you sure?

Because I have thoughts, and judging by your expression, you may not have been emotionally prepared for all of them.

Now, I'm not suggesting we should go around announcing every opinion that crosses our minds. Some thoughts need to stay right where they are.

I've had entire conversations in my head that absolutely did not need to become public knowledge.

And occasionally, I've even managed to keep my mouth shut.

Growth.

But there's a difference between being unnecessarily rude and simply not agreeing with someone.

If you ask whether I like something and I don't, what exactly are my options? Tell the truth or perform a convincing interpretation of enthusiasm?

"Oh, I LOVE it!"

Meanwhile, my face has already filed a formal objection.

This is why I appreciate people who understand that honesty doesn't always come wrapped in a compliment.

You can dislike something without insulting the person who likes it.

At least, that's how I thought it worked.

Apparently, Having an Opinion Is a Personality Flaw

I watch enough reality television to know that people can witness the exact same situation and come away with completely different interpretations.

And I have opinions.

Plenty of them.

There have been contestants I couldn't understand anyone supporting, people who stayed on shows long after I thought they should have gone home, and relationships that had me questioning whether everyone involved was watching the same footage.

But that's part of the entertainment.

What fascinates me is how seriously people take disagreements about these shows.

You say you don't like a contestant, and suddenly somebody is explaining why your opinion reveals something troubling about your character.

Ma'am.

We're discussing a person who voluntarily signed up to argue with strangers on television.

Can we maintain a little perspective?

I can disagree with your favorite contestant, question their decisions, and still think you're a perfectly lovely person.

You're wrong about the contestant, obviously.

But lovely nonetheless.

And that's the thing. Disagreement doesn't have to mean disrespect.

Sometimes two people simply see things differently.

A revolutionary concept, apparently.

Social Media Has Given Everyone a Microphone

And some people really should have left theirs on mute.

I enjoy social media. I like conversations, interesting perspectives, and occasionally reading comments that are more entertaining than the original post.

But the confidence people have when discussing complete strangers is something else.

A woman posts a picture of a beautiful handbag.

Within minutes, somebody is questioning her financial priorities, another person is explaining what she should have invested the money in, and a third has apparently reviewed her entire household budget.

All from a handbag.

I enjoy nice things. Beautiful hotels, lovely homes, a good handbag, and experiences that make life enjoyable.

There's nothing inherently irresponsible about appreciating luxury, just as there's nothing inherently impressive about spending money.

Context matters.

But the internet rarely waits around for context.

Somebody posts a vacation photo, and suddenly strangers are debating whether they should have paid off their mortgage instead.

Perhaps they already did.

Perhaps they saved for the trip.

Perhaps their finances are none of your business.

Just throwing out possibilities here.

The interesting part is that these same people will tell you how important it is to live authentically.

Apparently, that freedom doesn't extend to purchasing something they wouldn't have chosen.

Being Introverted Doesn't Mean I Don't Have Opinions

Here's something I've noticed about myself.

I'm an introvert. I'm not generally the person walking into a room full of strangers and immediately becoming everybody's new best friend.

Some people can attend an event, exchange phone numbers with twelve people, and leave with three lunch invitations.

I'm usually just pleased I made it through the event without having to introduce myself to the entire room.

But being quiet in certain situations doesn't mean I don't have thoughts.

Oh, I have thoughts.

Sometimes several competing opinions about the same situation.

The difference is that I'm not always interested in sharing them with everyone.

And when I do speak up, I'd prefer not to have to spend the next twenty minutes explaining that having an opinion doesn't mean I'm upset.

I'm not angry.

I'm not offended.

I simply disagree.

There is a difference.

Of course, my facial expressions occasionally complicate matters.

My mouth may be doing an excellent job of remaining diplomatic while my face has decided to hold a press conference.

We're working on that.

Let's Talk About People Who Are "Just Being Real"

Because authenticity has also become a very convenient excuse for bad behavior.

You know the person.

"I'm just brutally honest."

Usually said immediately after delivering an opinion nobody requested in the first place.

And somehow, they're always surprised when people don't appreciate it.

Well, congratulations on your honesty.

Have you considered trying kindness as well?

There's a difference between telling someone the truth and making sure the truth leaves a bruise.

Being authentic doesn't require you to be unnecessarily harsh.

Sometimes the kindest thing is to choose your words carefully. Other times, it's recognizing that nobody asked for your assessment of the situation.

For example, if a friend is excited about a new outfit, there is absolutely no reason to announce that you personally would never wear it.

Wonderful.

Then don't.

Problem solved.

We can have preferences without turning them into public service announcements.

And we can be honest without making honesty sound like a threat.

The Problem With Being the Agreeable One

I think many women can relate to this.

For years, we're encouraged to be pleasant, accommodating, and easy to get along with.

Don't make things awkward.

Try not to hurt anyone's feelings.

Be flexible.

And there's nothing wrong with being considerate. I actually think consideration is becoming a rather underrated quality.

The trouble starts when keeping everyone comfortable means constantly making yourself uncomfortable.

Maybe you agree to plans you don't particularly want to attend. Pretend to enjoy something because everyone else seems excited. Or stay quiet during a conversation because you know your opinion will be unpopular.

I've certainly had moments when keeping the peace seemed easier than explaining myself.

Especially when I could already tell the conversation was going to require more energy than I wanted to contribute.

But there's a difference between choosing not to engage and feeling like you aren't allowed to disagree.

Eventually, people get so accustomed to your cooperation that the first time you say no, they act like you've undergone a complete personality transformation.

"What happened to you?"

Nothing dramatic.

I just don't want to do that.

No tragic backstory. No spiritual awakening. No mysterious new influence.

I simply have a preference.

And apparently, that's going to take some getting used to.

Not Every Opinion Needs a Debate

Here's where I've changed as I've gotten older.

I still enjoy a good discussion. Give me an interesting topic and people who can disagree respectfully, and I'm happy to participate.

But I'm much less interested in arguing just for the sake of proving a point.

Some people genuinely want to understand another perspective.

Others are simply waiting for you to finish talking so they can explain why you're wrong.

You can usually tell the difference.

And while I appreciate a healthy debate, I have absolutely no desire to spend my afternoon defending my position to someone who has already decided what I think, why I think it, and what it supposedly says about my character.

At some point, the conversation stops being interesting.

I can listen to another person's opinion without adopting it.

They can hear mine without approving it.

We can even leave the conversation thinking exactly what we thought when we arrived.

Imagine that.

Two adults having different opinions and nobody needing to issue a public apology afterward.

You Can Change Your Mind, Too

There's another part of authenticity that doesn't get nearly enough attention.

The freedom to change your mind.

I have opinions today that aren't the same as the ones I held ten or twenty years ago.

Some changed because I learned something new. Others shifted because life gave me a different perspective.

And a few probably changed because I finally admitted that something I thought I liked was never really my thing.

That's allowed.

Yet people can be remarkably uncomfortable when someone changes their position.

"But you said..."

Yes.

I did.

And now I think something different.

Would you prefer that I continue defending an opinion I no longer believe simply for the sake of consistency?

That seems like a strange commitment.

Being authentic doesn't mean choosing a personality at twenty-five and refusing to update it for the next forty years.

I'd like to think I'm still learning.

Even if I occasionally need to be dragged toward a new perspective.

So, Which Version of Me Did You Want?

The older I get, the less interested I am in being universally agreeable.

That doesn't mean I've suddenly developed a desire to offend people or announce every thought that crosses my mind.

Quite the opposite.

I value kindness. I appreciate good manners. And I genuinely enjoy being around people who can have thoughtful conversations without turning everything into a competition.

But I also want the freedom to be myself.

To have preferences.

To disagree.

To say something sarcastic without having to provide a written explanation.

To change my mind when I learn something new.

And occasionally to look at something everyone else seems to love and think, "I don't get it."

Because I won't always agree with you.

You won't always agree with me.

Sometimes one of us will make an excellent point and the other will reconsider.

Other times, we'll both remain convinced we're right.

And if we can still laugh together afterward, even better.

That's the kind of authenticity I appreciate.

Not the performative version where everybody announces how unapologetically themselves they are while expecting the rest of the world to applaud.

The everyday version.

Where people can be different, honest, imperfect, occasionally sarcastic, and still treat each other with respect.

Because everybody says they want authenticity. The real question is whether they still want it when it doesn't come with their preferred opinion attached.

And if the answer is no, perhaps what they were looking for wasn't authenticity.

Perhaps they were looking for an echo.

Which is fine, I suppose.

Just don't ask me what I think if you've already decided what I'm supposed to say.

Next
Next

When Did Everything Become So Serious?